She listened to him say what he did, still looking at that star she found so intriguing, and smiled. It was a bit of a lopsided smile, but a smile nonetheless.

"I know you don't really like to sing in front of other people, and... I have to say, I was really surprised at that myself. But I loved it. I still do..." She also might have the songs burned onto her computer so she didn't wear out the CD she was given... and she may have copied that CD and kept the original in its case in her bag so that nothing happened to it. These things might have happened.